Is Bitcoin suitable as a financial asset? – A comprehensive analysis
Is Bitcoin suitable as a financial asset? – A comprehensive analysis

Bitcoin, as the first decentralized digital currency, has gained considerable attentionsince its introduction by Satoshi Nakamoto in 2009At its core, Bitcoin is based on blockchain technology, which records transactions in a public, immutable ledger. This eliminates the need for a central authority, such as a bank, and allows users to transact directly with each other. This decentralization and transparency are the key features that make Bitcoin unique.

The idea behind Bitcoin is simple: to create a digital money system that functions independently of government control or centralized financial institutions. Users hold their Bitcoin in digital wallets and can send and receive it worldwide without intermediaries. This system offers a form of money that is resistant to inflation, as the total amount is limited to 21 million Bitcoin.

The value proposition of Bitcoin

Bitcoin offers a unique value proposition that sets it apart from traditional financial systems and other cryptocurrencies. This is based on a combination of decentralization, security, scarcity and global accessibility. These features create a robust digital money system that is attractive to a wide range of users.

Decentralization and control

Bitcoin is the first decentralized digital money system that does not require a central controlling authority. This means that no bank or government has control over Bitcoin transactions. Instead, transactions are verified and stored by a peer-to-peer network and blockchain technology. Each participant in the network owns a copy of the blockchain, making manipulation virtually impossible.

A key feature of Bitcoin is the possibility of real ownership. In the traditional financial system, banks hold control over users’ money. With Bitcoin, however, the user himself holds the private keys to his digital wallet. This means that only the user has access to their Bitcoin and no central institution can take it away or deny access.

Security through proof-of-work

The security of Bitcoin is based on the proof-of-work mechanism. Miners solve complex mathematical problems to verify transactions and add new blocks to the blockchain. This process requires considerable computing power and energy, which makes the network extremely resistant to attacks. An attacker would have to combine more computing power than the entire network to manipulate a transaction, which is practically impossible.

Limited supply and inflation protection

A key advantage of Bitcoin is its limited supply. There will only be 21 million Bitcoin in total. This limited supply makes Bitcoin a deflationary currency, as no new Bitcoin can be created beyond this limit. In contrast, governments regularly print new money, which leads to inflation and a fall in the value of currencies.

To date, there are approximately 19 million Bitcoin in circulation, and the production of new Bitcoin halves every four years in an event known as “halving”. This event reduces the reward for mining new blocks and therefore reduces the rate at which new Bitcoin enters circulation. This scarcity makes Bitcoin an attractive store of value, especially in times of high inflation.

Global accessibility and independence

Bitcoin provides global access to a reliable monetary system. In many parts of the world, people do not have access to stable financial systems or trustworthy banks. Bitcoin allows these people to participate in the global economy without having to rely on local financial institutions.

Another advantage of Bitcoin is that transactions can be made without authorization. Users do not need to obtain permission from banks or other central institutions to carry out transactions. This makes Bitcoin particularly useful in regions with restrictive financial controls or unstable political situations.

Comparison with gold and other assets

Bitcoin is often referred to as digital gold, as it has similar characteristics to the precious metal, but with added benefits. Gold has historically served as a store of value, especially in times of economic uncertainty. Gold’s value is based on its scarcity and its long history as a store of value.

In comparison, Bitcoin offers even greater scarcity, as the supply is absolutely limited and the production of new units is regularly reduced. While gold sees an annual increase of around 1.5% of its total supply, the amount of new Bitcoin is halved every four years, resulting in an ever lower inflation rate. This characteristic makes Bitcoin a potentially better long-term store of value than gold.

Relevant article: Bitcoin and gold in comparison – An analysis of the current and future market situation in 2024

The importance of the network effect

The value of Bitcoin increases with the number of users. The more people use and accept Bitcoin, the more valuable the network becomes. This network effect leads to an exponential increase in value, as each new user makes the network more valuable for all existing users. This is similar to the effects observed in social networks such as Facebook or communication networks such as the telephone network.

One example of this is the increasing acceptance of Bitcoin by large financial institutions and companies. Companies such as Tesla, Square and MicroStrategy have added significant amounts of Bitcoin to their balance sheets, boosting confidence in Bitcoin as a store of value and further promoting its adoption.

Bitcoin as a financial asset

Bitcoin has become a significant financial asset since its inception and is attracting increasing interest from investors worldwide. This chapter examines the various aspects of Bitcoin as a financial asset in detail, including its performance, volatility, correlation with other assets and role in a diversified portfolio.

Performance and volatility

Bitcoin has experienced an impressive increase in value, making it an attractive asset class. Since its launch in 2009, the price of Bitcoin has gone through several ups and downs, but the long-term trend is clearly upwards. For example, the price of Bitcoin rose from around USD 7,000 at the beginning of 2020 to over USD 60,000 in 2021 before fluctuating in the following years.

Bitcoin Price Chart Alltime

Bitcoin price chart (Image: Tradingview)

Bitcoin’s average annual return has been remarkably high. Although the price has fallen by 50% or more several times, the price has doubled on average about every four years. This high volatility is a characteristic feature of Bitcoin and sets it apart from traditional financial assets such as stocks and bonds.

An example of this volatility can be seen in 2021, when Bitcoin fell from a high of around $64,000 in April to around $30,000 in July before recovering. Such fluctuations can be challenging for investors, but also offer opportunities for high returns.

Correlation with traditional investments

Another important aspect of Bitcoin as a financial asset is its low correlation with traditional investments such as stocks, bonds and real estate. Correlation measures how strongly the price movements of two different assets are related. A low or negative correlation means that Bitcoin tends to act independently of the movements of traditional markets.

This makes Bitcoin an attractive diversifying asset in a portfolio. In a diversified portfolio, low correlation investments can help reduce risk and increase stability. For example, if stock markets fall, Bitcoin could remain stable or even rise, helping to reduce the overall volatility of the portfolio.

An example of this is Bitcoin’s correlation with the NASDAQ index. Although Bitcoin has at times had a higher correlation with technology stocks in recent years, this relationship is not constant and has changed over time. This shows that Bitcoin reacts differently in different market phases, making it a valuable addition to a diversified portfolio.

Diversification benefits and portfolio allocation

Bitcoin’s diversification benefits can have a significant impact in a portfolio. Adding Bitcoin can reduce the volatility of the overall portfolio and improve risk-adjusted returns. This is because Bitcoin tends to react differently than traditional financial assets to macroeconomic events and market conditions.

The optimal allocation of Bitcoin in a portfolio depends on several factors, including the investor’s risk appetite, investment objectives and investment horizon. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, but many financial experts recommend an allocation of 1% to 10% of the portfolio in Bitcoin, depending on individual circumstances.

For long-term investors who are willing to tolerate short-term volatility, a higher allocation may make sense. Studies have shown that a moderate allocation of Bitcoin in a traditional portfolio can increase overall returns without disproportionately increasing risk.

Long-term perspective and market acceptance

In the long term, Bitcoin has the potential to establish itself as a major asset class, similar to gold. The limited supply and increasing adoption by institutional investors is helping to position Bitcoin as a form of digital gold. Companies such as Tesla, Square and MicroStrategy have added Bitcoin to their balance sheets, boosting confidence in Bitcoin as a store of value.

The increasing market acceptance is also reflected in the development of financial products such as Bitcoin ETFs and futures. These products enable institutional and private investors to trade Bitcoin in regulated markets, further increasing the liquidity and stability of the Bitcoin market.

One example of growing adoption is the Bitcoin ETF from ProShares, which debuted on the New York Stock Exchange in October 2021. This was a significant milestone as it represents the first exchange-traded fund to track Bitcoin price movements and allows investors to gain Bitcoin exposure without holding the cryptocurrency directly.

Risks and challenges

Despite the numerous benefits, there are also significant risks and challenges associated with Bitcoin as a financial asset. The high volatility can be problematic for short-term investors and can lead to significant losses. Regulatory uncertainties also pose a risk, as governments around the world take different approaches to regulating cryptocurrencies.

Another risk is security. Although the Bitcoin network itself is extremely secure, individual wallets and exchanges are vulnerable to hacks and theft. Investors need to ensure that they keep their Bitcoin safe, for example in hardware wallets that are less vulnerable to digital attacks.

The risks of Bitcoin

Although Bitcoin offers numerous benefits, there are also significant risks associated with its use and investment. These risks are manifold and relate to the market as well as the regulatory and technological landscape. In this chapter, the most important risks of Bitcoin are examined in detail and illustrated with facts and figures.

Market risk and volatility

One of the biggest risks of Bitcoin is its high volatility. The price of Bitcoin can fluctuate dramatically in a short period of time, which can lead to significant losses for investors. For example, in 2021, the Bitcoin price fell from a high of around USD 64,000 in April to around USD 30,000 in July within a few months. Such fluctuations are typical for Bitcoin and can pose a challenge for investors.

Bitcoin’s volatility is due to several factors, including market news, regulatory announcements and the general market environment. These factors can lead to sudden and unexpected price movements that are difficult to predict. Investors must therefore be prepared to tolerate these fluctuations and should only invest money that they could lose in a worst-case scenario.

Regulatory risks

Regulatory uncertainty is another significant risk for Bitcoin. As Bitcoin is a relatively new asset class, governments around the world are still developing their approaches to regulating cryptocurrencies. These regulations can have a significant impact on the use and trading of Bitcoin.

One example of regulatory risk is China’s crackdown on Bitcoin. China has taken multiple measures to ban the trading and mining of Bitcoin, which has led to significant price declines. Despite these measures, Bitcoin has proven resilient, but such regulatory interventions can lead to significant price fluctuations in the short term.

There is also regulatory uncertainty in the US. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has long rejected applications for Bitcoin ETFs, which has delayed the launch of such products. However, recent developments, such as the approval of a Bitcoin futures ETF, have shown that there is progress in regulatory acceptance.

Security risks

Security is another key risk associated with the use of Bitcoin. While the Bitcoin network itself is considered extremely secure, individual wallets and exchanges are vulnerable to hacks and theft. Examples of such security incidents include the hacks of Mt. Gox in 2014 and Bitfinex in 2016, where millions of Bitcoin were stolen in each case.

To minimize this risk, investors should store their Bitcoin in secure wallets. Hardware wallets that are kept offline offer the best protection against digital attacks. Investors should also use strong passwords and keep their private keys secure to prevent unauthorized access.

Relevant article: Mt. Gox creditors finally get their money back – details

Technological risks

Technological risks relate to the underlying infrastructure of Bitcoin. Although the Bitcoin network is considered secure and stable, there are potential threats, such as the development of quantum computers. Quantum computers could theoretically overcome Bitcoin’s cryptographic security, which would jeopardize the entire network.

However, developers are already working on solutions to protect Bitcoin against such threats. For example, quantum-resistant algorithms could be introduced to ensure the security of the network. However, these measures would require significant changes to the Bitcoin protocol and would need to be carefully implemented.

Liquidity risks

Another risk is the liquidity of Bitcoin. Although Bitcoin is traded on many exchanges around the world, liquidity can dry up quickly in times of high volatility or regulatory intervention. This can lead to greater price differences between different exchanges and make it more difficult to buy or sell Bitcoin at a fair market price.

For example, during the market crash in March 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic shook financial markets worldwide, Bitcoin’s liquidity was significantly impacted. In such times, it can be difficult for investors to trade large amounts of Bitcoin without significantly affecting the market price.

Systemic risks

Bitcoin is also potentially vulnerable to systemic risks that can be caused by external factors. These include economic crises, geopolitical tensions or widespread technical failures. Such events can shake investor confidence in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies and lead to significant price declines.

One example of systemic risk is dependence on the internet infrastructure. As Bitcoin is entirely based on the internet, a large-scale outage of internet connections could affect the entire network. While such scenarios are unlikely, they are not impossible and must be taken into account when assessing the risks of Bitcoin.

The future valuation of Bitcoin

The future valuation of Bitcoin is a topic that is of great concern to both investors and experts. Various models and theories offer approaches for estimating the future value of Bitcoin. In this chapter, some of these models are presented and explained using facts and figures from the past and present.

The stock-to-flow model

The stock-to-flow (S2F) model is one of the best-known models for valuing Bitcoin. Originally used for commodities such as gold, the S2F model measures the ratio of existing inventory (stock) to annual production (flow). A higher S2F ratio indicates a higher scarcity, which typically leads to a higher value.

Bitcoin Stock to flow chart

Bitcoin Stock to Flow Chart (Source: LookIntoBitcoin)

Bitcoin has a very high S2F ratio, which is further increased by regular halvings. During a halving, the reward for mining new blocks is halved, which reduces the amount of newly generated Bitcoin. The last halving took place in April 2020, halving the annual supply of new Bitcoin.

Currently, the S2F ratio of Bitcoin is around 56, which means that the ratio of existing Bitcoin to new Bitcoin is very high. In comparison, the S2F ratio of gold is around 62. According to the S2F model, the value of Bitcoin will continue to rise as supply remains limited in relation to demand. Based on this model, the price of Bitcoin could rise to over 1 million US dollars by 2025 if current trends continue.

Metcalfe’s law

Another model for valuing Bitcoin is Metcalfe‘s Law, which states that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of its users. This model was originally used to value telecommunications networks and social networks such as Facebook. Since Bitcoin is also a network, this model can be applied to Bitcoin.

The number of Bitcoin users is constantly growing, and the more people use Bitcoin, the more valuable the network becomes. According to some estimates, Bitcoin could have more than 200 million users by 2030. Applying Metcalfe’s law, the value of Bitcoin could increase significantly as network effects increase.

Comparison with other stores of value

Another approach to valuing Bitcoin is to compare it to other stores of value such as gold, real estate and stocks. The global market for stores of value has an estimated volume of around 900 trillion US dollars. Bitcoin currently has a market capitalization of around USD 1 trillion, which is only a small fraction of this market.

If Bitcoin takes up just 5% of the total store of value market over the next few years, its market capitalization could rise to USD 45 trillion. This would correspond to a Bitcoin price of over 2 million US dollars. Even a more conservative estimate of 1% of the market would mean a Bitcoin price of over USD 400,000.

Potential for institutional investment

Another factor that could influence the future valuation of Bitcoin is the increasing interest of institutional investors. Companies such as Tesla, Square and MicroStrategy have already added significant amounts of Bitcoin to their balance sheets. In addition, large financial institutions such as BlackRock and Fidelity have shown interest in Bitcoin and cryptocurrency products.

Institutional investment could significantly increase demand for Bitcoin and drive the price up further. According to some analysts, the market capitalization of Bitcoin could rise to several trillion US dollars over the next few years as a result of institutional investment.

Influence of macroeconomic factors

Macroeconomic factors also play an important role in the valuation of Bitcoin. In times of economic uncertainty and high inflation, investors look for safe havens to protect their wealth. Bitcoin, with its limited supply and decentralized nature, is increasingly seen as such a hedge.

For example, the price of Bitcoin rose significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic as governments around the world printed large amounts of money to support the economy. Such measures often lead to inflation and currency devaluation, which increases the attractiveness of Bitcoin as a store of value.

PlanB’s model and forecasts

The anonymous analyst PlanB further developed the S2F model and published an extended version called S2FX. This model views Bitcoin as a series of phase transitions, similar to the introduction of fiat currencies and precious metals. According to the S2FX model, Bitcoin could reach a price of 288,000 US dollars by 2024 and continue to rise in the following years.

PlanB’s models are based on the historical price development of Bitcoin and the regular halvings. However, they are not uncontroversial and should be interpreted with caution. There are many variables that can influence the price of Bitcoin and no forecast can offer absolute certainty.

What is Metcalfe’s Law?

Metcalfe’s Law, formulated by Robert Metcalfe, the co-developer of Ethernet, states that the value of a network grows exponentially with the square of the number of its users. This means that the benefits and value of a network not only increase linearly, but dramatically as more participants join the network. This concept illustrates the enormous power of network effects.

Metcalfe’s law and its application

Metcalfe’s law is a fundamental principle in network economics and is often used to evaluate communication and social networks. It shows that each new member of a network increases the number of possible connections within the network, which increases the total value for all existing and new members. 

For example, if a network has two members, there is only one connection. If the network grows to four members, the number of connections increases to six. This exponential growth of connections leads to a strong increase in network value.

Visualization of the network effect

The network effect, visualized by Metcalfe’s law, shows that each new connection in the network increases its overall utility and value. This positive feedback effect can lead to rapid growth and high adoption as more and more people recognize the value of the network and join it. A well known example is the telephone network: a single phone is worthless, but the value of the network increases exponentially with each new phone that is added.

Application to cryptocurrencies

Metcalfe’s law is particularly relevant in the field of cryptocurrencies. Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum are networks that depend on the number of their users and the amount of transactions carried out. The more people use these networks, the more valuable and robust they become. 

For cryptocurrencies, this means that the value of a digital asset increases as the user base grows. This increase in value can be measured in a number of ways, including the number of active addresses, transaction volume and network activity. These metrics provide insights into the growth and adoption of the network.

Impact on price dynamics

Applying Metcalfe’s Law to cryptocurrencies shows that a growing user base can increase the demand and therefore the price of a digital asset. One example of this is Bitcoin: since its launch, the number of Bitcoin users and transactions has steadily increased, which has led to a significant rise in the price of Bitcoin. 
According to Metcalfe’s law, the value of Bitcoin could continue to rise if the user base grows exponentially. This also applies to other cryptocurrencies that benefit from network effects.

Using Metcalfe’s law for crypto investments

Metcalfe’s Law can be a valuable tool for crypto investors to evaluate the growth potential of a cryptocurrency. By analyzing metrics such as active addresses, transaction volume and user engagement, investors can assess the strength of network effects and the future growth potential of a digital asset.

Investors who understand Metcalfe’s Law can better assess how a growing user base will impact the value of a cryptocurrency. This enables informed investment decisions and helps to better assess potential opportunities and risks.

Limitations of Metcalfe’s law

While Metcalfe’s Law provides a valuable framework for assessing network value, it also has its limitations. It is important to recognize that the law is only one part of the overall valuation process. Other factors such as technological advances, regulatory developments, market sentiment and macroeconomic trends can also have a significant impact on the value and adoption of cryptocurrencies.

A comprehensive assessment of all relevant factors is crucial to making informed investment decisions. Metcalfe’s Law provides a useful perspective, but should not be considered in isolation.

Conclusion

Bitcoin embodies a unique combination of decentralization, security, scarcity and global accessibility. These characteristics make Bitcoin a revolutionary financial instrument that has the potential to challenge traditional monetary systems and play a significant role in the global economy. With the ability to hold real property, Bitcoin offers a new form of financial freedom that is becoming increasingly important in the modern world.

As a financial asset, Bitcoin has established itself through its high yield, low correlation with traditional assets and growing acceptance by institutional investors. These characteristics make it an attractive addition to diversified portfolios. However, investors need to carefully consider the risks and volatility associated with Bitcoin. With thoughtful analysis and a well-considered allocation, Bitcoin can add significant value and minimize risk to a portfolio.

Despite its benefits, Bitcoin carries significant risks. The high volatility, regulatory uncertainties, security threats, technological risks, liquidity issues and systemic risks make Bitcoin a risky but potentially rewarding investment. Investors should be aware of these risks and take appropriate measures to protect their investments. A well-thought-out investment strategy and a long-term horizon can help to mitigate the risks and maximize the chances of high returns.

The future valuation of Bitcoin is complex and is influenced by numerous factors. Models such as the stock-to-flow ratio, Metcalfe’s law and comparison with other stores of value offer different approaches to estimating the future value of Bitcoin. Macroeconomic factors and growing interest from institutional investors could further drive demand for Bitcoin.

While the models and forecasts are optimistic, investors should keep an eye on the inherent risks and uncertainties. The future development of Bitcoin remains exciting and offers both opportunities and challenges.

Metcalfe’s Law provides valuable insights into the dynamics of networks and their exponential increase in value due to growing user numbers. In the field of cryptocurrencies, it underlines the importance of network effects for the success and valuation of digital assets. By analyzing the user base and network activity, investors can better understand the growth potential and long-term sustainability of cryptocurrencies and make informed investment decisions.

In summary, Bitcoin offers significant opportunities and risks. As a decentralized, secure and limited digital currency, it has the potential to fundamentally change the financial landscape. However, investors should take into account the high volatility and regulatory uncertainties. With careful analysis and a well-thought-out investment strategy, Bitcoin can be a valuable addition to traditional investment portfolios.

Author

Ed Prinz serves as Chairman of https://dltaustria.com, the most renowned non-profit organization in Austria specializing in blockchain technology. DLT Austria is actively involved in the education and promotion of the added value and application possibilities of distributed ledger technology. This is done through educational events, meetups, workshops and open discussions, all in voluntary collaboration with leading industry players.

👉 Telegram
👉 Website
👉 LinkedIn

Disclaimer

This is my personal opinion and not financial advice. For this reason, I cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information in this article. If you are unsure, you should consult a qualified advisor you trust. No guarantees or promises regarding profits are made in this article. All statements in this and other articles are my personal opinion.

By Ed Prinz

Ed Prinz co-founded https://loob.io, a digital marketplace for blockchain-secured assets, and chairs https://dltaustria.com, a leading blockchain non-profit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *